Returns fraud is a growing concern for e-commerce merchants, costing the industry billions of dollars annually. While a flexible return policy is essential for customer satisfaction, it can also be exploited by fraudsters through tactics like returning used items, claiming non-receipt, or even using stolen payment information to make purchases. Striking a balance between offering a seamless return process and protecting your business from fraud is crucial.

In this article, we will explore strategies e-commerce merchants can use to reduce returns fraud without compromising the customer experience.

Setting Clear Expectations

Implement Clear and Detailed Return Policies

A well-structured return policy is one of the first lines of defense against fraudulent returns. By clearly outlining your rules and procedures, you can set expectations for legitimate customers while discouraging fraudulent behavior.

What to Include:

• Time Limits: Set strict time frames for returns (e.g., 14 or 30 days after purchase) to reduce the likelihood of customers trying to return products after excessive use.
• Condition of Return: Clearly state that items must be in their original condition, unused, and in the original packaging. For products like electronics, apparel, and accessories, consider requiring tags to be attached or security seals to remain intact.
• Non-Returnable Items: Identify which items are final sale or non-returnable, such as clearance items, digital goods, or products that are easily resold (e.g., high-end fashion or electronics). This can help mitigate risks of abuse.
• Restocking Fees: For high-ticket items or certain categories, implementing a restocking fee can deter fraudulent or excessive returns without alienating honest customers.

Offer Store Credit Instead of Refunds

A common tactic for reducing returns fraud is offering store credit as a refund option, particularly for high-risk categories or products. While legitimate customers can still exchange items or use the credit for future purchases, fraudsters are less likely to exploit this policy as it limits their ability to get direct cash refunds.

Benefits of Store Credit:

• Loyalty Building: Offering store credit can encourage customers to remain loyal to your brand and make future purchases.
• Fraud Deterrence: Since fraudsters often aim to receive cash, providing store credit can discourage attempts at returns fraud.
• Custom Credit Expiration: You can set expiration dates on store credit to ensure it’s used within a specific timeframe, further reducing risks of long-term fraud.

Communicate Clearly with Customers

Fraud often occurs when return policies or product details are unclear. Communicating openly and transparently with your customers can help reduce the likelihood of misunderstandings that lead to fraudulent returns.

What to Focus On:

• Detailed Product Information: Ensure that product descriptions, images, and specifications are accurate and clear to prevent customers from feeling misled, which can lead to returns (fraudulent or otherwise).
• Return Policy Transparency: Place your return policy in visible locations across your website, such as the footer, product pages, and checkout. Make the terms clear and concise, so customers know exactly what to expect.
• Prompt Customer Support: Offer real-time customer support through live chat or AI chatbots to resolve any issues or concerns customers have before they initiate a return.

Limit or Flag High-Risk Orders

Some orders may pose a higher risk of returns fraud based on factors such as the type of product, the customer’s return history, or the location of the order. Setting up safeguards for these high-risk situations can help prevent fraud before it happens.

Best Practices for High-Risk Orders:

• Flag Large or High-Value Orders: Require additional verification or approval for high-value purchases or bulk orders to ensure legitimacy.
• Limit Serial Returners: Customers with a history of frequent returns may be subject to stricter return conditions, such as offering store credit only, shorter return windows, or mandatory inspections.
• International Orders: Be extra cautious with international orders, especially from regions known for higher fraud rates. Ensure you have strong fraud detection in place for these transactions.

Reviewing and Managing Returns Claims

Track Customer Return Patterns

Not all customers who return products are engaging in fraud, but identifying patterns can help detect potential fraudsters. By using data analytics, you can spot trends such as frequent returns, high-value item returns, or customers who frequently claim items were “never received.”

How to Use Data Analytics:

• Flag High-Risk Customers: Set up automated systems that flag customers who frequently return items, especially if they regularly return high-value or seasonal products.
• Monitor Inconsistent Return Reasons: Pay attention to customers who frequently give vague or inconsistent reasons for returning products (e.g., claiming “defective” for multiple items) or those who use similar phrasing across several returns.
• Geographic Patterns: Analyze geographic trends in returns, as certain regions or shipping addresses might be linked to higher incidences of returns fraud.

Use Advanced Technology for Fraud Detection

Leveraging technology to identify potential returns fraud before it happens can protect your business. Fraud detection systems use algorithms and machine learning to assess risks based on user behavior, return patterns, and other red flags. Since most returns fraud happens at the time of purchase, consider using a fraud reduction platform like Signifyd and Forter offer AI-driven fraud detection tools that assess the risk of a transaction or return before processing. These systems can spot unusual patterns, such as the use of stolen payment information or frequent returns.

Verify and Inspect Returned Products

Having a clear process for inspecting returned items before issuing refunds or credits can help identify fraudulent returns. This is particularly important for high-value items or those prone to abuse, such as clothing, electronics, and cosmetics.

Best Practices for Inspections:

• Check for Wear and Tear: Ensure the product hasn’t been used, damaged, or altered. Look for signs of wear, opened packaging, or missing accessories.
• Test Electronics: For returned electronics or appliances, run diagnostic tests to verify that the item is functioning properly and hasn’t been tampered with or replaced with a faulty product.
• Security Seals: Use tamper-evident packaging or security seals on products, which can help identify if an item has been opened or altered.

Offer Transparent and Detailed Order Tracking, Plus Shipping Protection

Some fraudulent returns stem from false claims that a product was never delivered or that it arrived damaged. Providing transparent order tracking and proof of delivery can help prevent these types of scams.

How to Implement Effective Tracking:

• Track Shipping Progress: Provide customers with real-time tracking information that shows the shipping status of their order, including delivery confirmation.
• Signature Confirmation for High-Value Items: For expensive or high-risk products, require a signature upon delivery. This ensures the package is received by the intended recipient and can be used as proof in the event of a dispute.
• Photographic Evidence for Delivered Items: Some carriers offer photo confirmation of the delivery location, providing additional proof that the package was delivered correctly.

Corso can help ensure that your shipments are both properly tracked AND protected, at no additional cost to you.

Require Return Authorization (RMA) Numbers

Implementing a return merchandise authorization (RMA) system adds a layer of control to your return process. Customers must request an RMA number before returning an item, allowing you to review the return request for red flags before approving it.

Benefits of RMA Systems:

• Pre-Approval: By reviewing the reason for return and details of the transaction, you can identify potential fraud before the return is processed.
• Tracking Returns: The RMA number allows for better tracking of each return, helping you monitor if an item is genuinely returned and in the proper condition.
• Preventing Abuse: Since the RMA process requires additional steps, it can deter fraudsters looking for a quick and easy return process.

Conclusion

Returns fraud is a costly challenge for e-commerce merchants, but with the right strategies in place, it can be significantly reduced. By creating a clear and comprehensive return policy, using advanced fraud detection technology, tracking customer return behavior, and implementing proactive measures like RMA numbers and return inspections, merchants can protect their business from fraudulent returns. While it’s important to maintain a customer-friendly return process, adding protective layers can safeguard your profits and ensure that returns fraud doesn’t become a major threat to your e-commerce operation.

• Post-purchase strategies for customer retention
• How to Design and Implement a Loyalty Program
• Increasing Retention Through Customer Feedback
• Gamification for Customer Retention

• Tracking Page Strategies
• Optimizing Your Returns Landing Page

• Balancing Costs and Customer Experience With Return Fees
• Improving Customer LTV Post-Purchase
• Marketing to Existing Customers